Skip to content
New

DeepSeek V4.1 Flash free for 7 days: 10M tokens a day after a top-up of $10 or more. Until Nov 30.

How it works
trailofbits/variant-analysisWeb and bug bounty

variant-analysis

⁨Hunts for the other instances of a bug already found — the variants of one root cause across a codebase. Use immediately after a vulnerability, logic bug, or bad pattern turns up in a specific file and the question becomes where else it occurs, including the bare conversational form ("are there othe⁩

v2026.11.12-149d7b23 installs+3 in 7 days8.2K StarsCC-BY-SA-4.0synced 22 hours ago

Install

No NotHoly CLI yet? Install it first.

$ curl -fsSL https://notholy.com/install.sh | sh
$ notholy skills install trailofbits/variant-analysis

Writes to ⁦~/.notholy/skills⁩ after checking the signature and the SHA-256.

SignatureSigned, ed25519
b4ZoDIM9Hy…UWgieaBw==The CLI checks the SHA-256 and the signature before it writes a file.
Package76be2c22…8194e76b
76be2c220a09…e1748194e76b18 files · ⁦14.6 KB⁩
ScanLow1 finding
  • Links to outside domains
See the full scan
Sourcegithub.com/trailofbits/skills/tree/main/plugins/variant-analysis/skills/variant-analysis@149d7b2

Find the other instances of a bug you have already found. One root cause usually has several manifestations, and they are rarely in the module where you found the first one.

When to Use

  • A vulnerability has been found and you need to search for similar instances
  • Building or refining CodeQL/Semgrep queries for security patterns
  • Performing systematic code audits after an initial issue discovery
  • Analyzing how a single root cause manifests in different code paths

When NOT to Use

  • Initial vulnerability discovery — use audit-context-building or a domain-specific audit
  • General code review with no known pattern to search for
  • Writing fix recommendations — use issue-writer
  • Understanding unfamiliar code — use audit-context-building first

The Five Steps

Read the reference for a step when you reach it.

1. Understand the original issue. Extract the root cause — why the code is wrong, not what it does — and enumerate the directions a variant could hide in: related identifiers, other manifestations of the same mistake, data-type edge cases. → references/root-cause.md

2. Create an exact match. Write a pattern matching ONLY the known instance and confirm it hits. A pattern that matches nothing means you have misunderstood the bug, and every search built on it is calibrated against the wrong code.

3–4. Generalize one element at a time. Climb from the exact match toward the pattern family, running and reading all matches after each single change. Stop when more than half the matches are noise. → references/searching.md — abstraction ladder, tool selection, false-positive filters

5. Triage. Decide which candidates are real, and say so with a severity attached. → references/triage.md

Then write it up, including the patterns that failed and a CI rule to prevent regression. → references/reporting.md

Running it as a Workflow

This plugin ships /variant-analysis:variants, which runs the five steps across parallel subagents — one per expansion axis, looping until the sweep stops finding anything new. Each stage reads the reference above that matches its job.

Use the workflow when the codebase is large or the root cause has many manifestations. Work the steps directly when the search is narrow or you want a say in each generalization.

What Makes Hunts Fail

  1. Narrow scope — searching only the module the original bug was in
  2. Pattern too specific — searching one attribute and missing the family around it
  3. One vulnerability class — chasing a single manifestation of the root cause
  4. Happy-path testing — never trying the null, empty, and boundary cases
  5. Generalizing too fast — abstracting several elements at once, so noise cannot be attributed to any one of them

The first three are covered in root-cause.md and searching.md, the fourth in triage.md.

Resources

CodeQL (resources/codeql/): python.ql, javascript.ql, java.ql, go.ql, cpp.ql

Semgrep (resources/semgrep/): python.yaml, javascript.yaml, java.yaml, go.yaml, cpp.yaml

Report: resources/variant-report-template.md

Files in this version

Permissions

PermissionDeclaredFound by the scan
Reads filesYesYes
Writes filesYesYes
Runs shell commandsYesYes
Uses the networkYesYes
Uses connectorsNoNo
Drives a browserNoNo

Scan findings

Reviewed on Nov 13, 2026

  1. InfoLink · Links to outside domains

A clean scan lowers the risk but does not prove a package is safe. Read what you install.

VersionPublishedCommitSHA-256SignaturePermission change
v2026.11.12-149d7b2Nov 13, 2026149d7b276be2c22Signed–

Ask anything your scope allows.

Create an account, add credits and ask the first question in the chat or the terminal.

  1. 1/3

    Create the account

    Individual or company. You can switch to a company later without losing balance or keys.

    IndividualCompany
  2. 2/3

    Add credits

    By card. Pay per token, no subscription.

    $5.00minimum deposit
  3. 3/3

    Ask

    In the chat, or install the CLI and run notholy login in your terminal.

    $ notholy login