analyzing-campaign-attribution-evidence
Systematically evaluate cyber-campaign evidence to attribute an operation to a threat actor, using the Diamond Model and Analysis of Competing Hypotheses (ACH) to weigh infrastructure overlaps, TTP consistency, malware code similarity, and timing/language artifacts into confidence-weighted attributi
v1.03 installs+3 in 7 days36.3K StarsApache-2.0synced 12 hours ago
Install
No NotHoly CLI yet? Install it first.
$ curl -fsSL https://notholy.com/install.sh | sh$ notholy skills install mukul975/analyzing-campaign-attribution-evidenceWrites to ~/.notholy/skills after checking the signature and the SHA-256.
SignatureSigned, ed25519
Package59e019c0…868ac6c0
59e019c03ad3…3e95868ac6c08 files · 13.4 KBScanMedium3 findings
- Executable script shipped with the skillscripts/agent.py
- Executable script shipped with the skillscripts/process.py
- Links to outside domains
Sourcegithub.com/mukul975/Anthropic-Cybersecurity-Skills/tree/main/skills/analyzing-campaign-attribution-evidence@54a7988
On this page
Overview
Campaign attribution analysis involves systematically evaluating evidence to determine which threat actor or group is responsible for a cyber operation. This skill covers collecting and weighting attribution indicators using the Diamond Model and ACH (Analysis of Competing Hypotheses), analyzing infrastructure overlaps, TTP consistency, malware code similarities, operational timing patterns, and language artifacts to build confidence-weighted attribution assessments.
When to Use
- When investigating security incidents that require analyzing campaign attribution evidence
- When building detection rules or threat hunting queries for this domain
- When SOC analysts need structured procedures for this analysis type
- When validating security monitoring coverage for related attack techniques
Prerequisites
- Python 3.9+ with
attackcti,stix2,networkxlibraries - Access to threat intelligence platforms (MISP, OpenCTI)
- Understanding of Diamond Model of Intrusion Analysis
- Familiarity with MITRE ATT&CK threat group profiles
- Knowledge of malware analysis and infrastructure tracking techniques
Key Concepts
Attribution Evidence Categories
- Infrastructure Overlap: Shared C2 servers, domains, IP ranges, hosting providers
- TTP Consistency: Matching ATT&CK techniques and sub-techniques across campaigns
- Malware Code Similarity: Shared code bases, compilers, PDB paths, encryption routines
- Operational Patterns: Timing (working hours, time zones), targeting patterns, operational tempo
- Language Artifacts: Embedded strings, variable names, error messages in specific languages
- Victimology: Target sector, geography, and organizational profile consistency
Confidence Levels
- High Confidence: Multiple independent evidence categories converge on same actor
- Moderate Confidence: Several evidence categories match, some ambiguity remains
- Low Confidence: Limited evidence, possible false flags or shared tooling
Analysis of Competing Hypotheses (ACH)
Structured analytical method that evaluates evidence against multiple competing hypotheses. Each piece of evidence is scored as consistent, inconsistent, or neutral with respect to each hypothesis. The hypothesis with the least inconsistent evidence is favored.
Workflow
Step 1: Collect Attribution Evidence
from stix2 import MemoryStore, Filter
from collections import defaultdict
class AttributionAnalyzer:
def __init__(self):
self.evidence = []
self.hypotheses = {}
def add_evidence(self, category, description, value, confidence):
self.evidence.append({
"category": category,
"description": description,
"value": value,
"confidence": confidence,
"timestamp": None,
})
def add_hypothesis(self, actor_name, actor_id=""):
self.hypotheses[actor_name] = {
"actor_id": actor_id,
"consistent_evidence": [],
"inconsistent_evidence": [],
"neutral_evidence": [],
"score": 0,
}
def evaluate_evidence(self, evidence_idx, actor_name, assessment):
"""Assess evidence against a hypothesis: consistent/inconsistent/neutral."""
if assessment == "consistent":
self.hypotheses[actor_name]["consistent_evidence"].append(evidence_idx)
self.hypotheses[actor_name]["score"] += self.evidence[evidence_idx]["confidence"]
elif assessment == "inconsistent":
self.hypotheses[actor_name]["inconsistent_evidence"].append(evidence_idx)
self.hypotheses[actor_name]["score"] -= self.evidence[evidence_idx]["confidence"] * 2
else:
self.hypotheses[actor_name]["neutral_evidence"].append(evidence_idx)
def rank_hypotheses(self):
"""Rank hypotheses by attribution score."""
ranked = sorted(
self.hypotheses.items(),
key=lambda x: x[1]["score"],
reverse=True,
)
return [
{
"actor": name,
"score": data["score"],
"consistent": len(data["consistent_evidence"]),
"inconsistent": len(data["inconsistent_evidence"]),
"confidence": self._score_to_confidence(data["score"]),
}
for name, data in ranked
]
def _score_to_confidence(self, score):
if score >= 80:
return "HIGH"
elif score >= 40:
return "MODERATE"
else:
return "LOW"Step 2: Infrastructure Overlap Analysis
def analyze_infrastructure_overlap(campaign_a_infra, campaign_b_infra):
"""Compare infrastructure between two campaigns for attribution."""
overlap = {
"shared_ips": set(campaign_a_infra.get("ips", [])).intersection(
campaign_b_infra.get("ips", [])
),
"shared_domains": set(campaign_a_infra.get("domains", [])).intersection(
campaign_b_infra.get("domains", [])
),
"shared_asns": set(campaign_a_infra.get("asns", [])).intersection(
campaign_b_infra.get("asns", [])
),
"shared_registrars": set(campaign_a_infra.get("registrars", [])).intersection(
campaign_b_infra.get("registrars", [])
),
}
overlap_score = 0
if overlap["shared_ips"]:
overlap_score += 30
if overlap["shared_domains"]:
overlap_score += 25
if overlap["shared_asns"]:
overlap_score += 15
if overlap["shared_registrars"]:
overlap_score += 10
return {
"overlap": {k: list(v) for k, v in overlap.items()},
"overlap_score": overlap_score,
"assessment": "STRONG" if overlap_score >= 40 else "MODERATE" if overlap_score >= 20 else "WEAK",
}Step 3: TTP Comparison Across Campaigns
from attackcti import attack_client
def compare_campaign_ttps(campaign_techniques, known_actor_techniques):
"""Compare campaign TTPs against known threat actor profiles."""
campaign_set = set(campaign_techniques)
actor_set = set(known_actor_techniques)
common = campaign_set.intersection(actor_set)
unique_campaign = campaign_set - actor_set
unique_actor = actor_set - campaign_set
jaccard = len(common) / len(campaign_set.union(actor_set)) if campaign_set.union(actor_set) else 0
return {
"common_techniques": sorted(common),
"common_count": len(common),
"unique_to_campaign": sorted(unique_campaign),
"unique_to_actor": sorted(unique_actor),
"jaccard_similarity": round(jaccard, 3),
"overlap_percentage": round(len(common) / len(campaign_set) * 100, 1) if campaign_set else 0,
}Step 4: Generate Attribution Report
def generate_attribution_report(analyzer):
"""Generate structured attribution assessment report."""
rankings = analyzer.rank_hypotheses()
report = {
"assessment_date": "2026-02-23",
"total_evidence_items": len(analyzer.evidence),
"hypotheses_evaluated": len(analyzer.hypotheses),
"rankings": rankings,
"primary_attribution": rankings[0] if rankings else None,
"evidence_summary": [
{
"index": i,
"category": e["category"],
"description": e["description"],
"confidence": e["confidence"],
}
for i, e in enumerate(analyzer.evidence)
],
}
return reportValidation Criteria
- Evidence collection covers all six attribution categories
- ACH matrix properly evaluates evidence against competing hypotheses
- Infrastructure overlap analysis identifies shared indicators
- TTP comparison uses ATT&CK technique IDs for precision
- Attribution confidence levels are properly justified
- Report includes alternative hypotheses and false flag considerations
References
Files in this version
assets/11003 B
- template.md1003 B
references/35.6 KB
- api-reference.md3.1 KB
- standards.md1.1 KB
- workflows.md1.4 KB
scripts/215.9 KB
- agent.py9.9 KB
- process.py5.9 KB
- LICENSE11.0 KB
- SKILL.md9.0 KB
Permissions
| Permission | Declared | Found by the scan |
|---|---|---|
| Reads files | No | No |
| Writes files | No | No |
| Runs shell commands | Yes | Yes |
| Uses the network | Yes | Yes |
| Uses connectors | No | No |
| Drives a browser | No | No |
Scan findings
Reviewed on Nov 13, 2026
- MediumFile · Executable script shipped with the skillscripts/agent.py
- MediumFile · Executable script shipped with the skillscripts/process.py
- InfoLink · Links to outside domains
A clean scan lowers the risk but does not prove a package is safe. Read what you install.
| Version | Published | Commit | SHA-256 | Signature | Permission change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| v1.0 | Nov 13, 2026 | 54a7988 | 59e019c0 | Signed | – |
More from mukul975
All from this publisher- testing-for-xml-injection-vulnerabilitiesmukul975/testing-for-xml-injection-vulnerabilities5
- testing-for-sensitive-data-exposuremukul975/testing-for-sensitive-data-exposure5
- performing-jwt-none-algorithm-attackmukul975/performing-jwt-none-algorithm-attack5
- detecting-aws-credential-exposure-with-trufflehogmukul975/detecting-aws-credential-exposure-with-trufflehog5
More in Malware and ransomware analysis
See the category- writing-yara-rules-from-reversed-codemeltedinhex/writing-yara-rules-from-reversed-code4
- yara-sigsdariushoule/yara-sigs4
- monitoring-darkweb-sourcesmukul975/monitoring-darkweb-sources3
- deploying-ransomware-canary-filesmukul975/deploying-ransomware-canary-files3
- implementing-honeypot-for-ransomware-detectionmukul975/implementing-honeypot-for-ransomware-detection3
- yaraaeondave/yara3
Ask anything your scope allows.
Create an account, add credits and ask the first question in the chat or the terminal.
- 1/3
Create the account
Individual or company. You can switch to a company later without losing balance or keys.
IndividualCompany - 2/3
Add credits
By card. Pay per token, no subscription.
$5.00minimum deposit - 3/3
Ask
In the chat, or install the CLI and run notholy login in your terminal.
$ notholy login